Stylized i character

None of our reviews are sponsored. We earn a commission when you purchase items through our links.

Updated

The Best 2 & 4 Slice Toasters


After more than 30 hours researching, toasting and tasting breads, bagels and breakfast pastries in seven of the best-selling top-slot toasters, we determined that the Cuisinart – Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster is the best toaster for everyday use. The Cuisinart stands out as the most consistent, even when toasting lots of toast back to back. If you need to conserve counter space, the Hamilton Beach – 22790 is a good 2-slice option.

Our Top Choices

Best Overall


Cuisinart

Touch to Toast

Best Value


Cuisinart

CPT-180 Classic

Most Versatile


Breville

BTA830XL Long Slot

Best 2-Slice


Hamilton Beach

22790

After more than 30 hours researching, toasting and tasting breads, bagels and breakfast pastries in seven of the best-selling top-slot toasters, we determined that the Cuisinart – Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster is the best toaster for everyday use. The Cuisinart stands out as the most consistent, even when toasting lots of toast back to back. If you need to conserve counter space, the Hamilton Beach – 22790 is a good 2-slice option.

Table of contents

How we selected finalists to test

We began our quest to find the best toaster by compiling reviews and research from popular sources on home goods like Consumer Reports, Good Housekeeping, CNET and Bon Appetit magazine.

We also read cooking blogs and talked to other consumers to discover how often people use a toaster, what functions are most useful, what the most common complaints are, and what makes a great toaster.

We found that these are the predominant characteristics that people look for in a good toaster:

  • Reliability: Does a given setting produce an expected result time after time?
  • Consistency: Is the food item toasted evenly over the entire surface?
  • Versatility: Can the toaster accommodate a wide variety of foods?
  • Aesthetics: How visually attractive is the appliance?
  • Footprint: How much counter space is used?
  • Features: Do special features work accurately and intuitively?
  • Cleaning: How easily can the appliance be cleared of crumbs and debris?
  • Affordability: Do better results necessarily require spending more money?

Compare the best toasters

other toasters

ToasterPriceSlicesToast Evenness (1–3)Consistency Across Batches (1–3)Bagel Setting (1–3)
01. Cuisinart - CPT-440 Touch to Toast$$4☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
02. Cuisinart - CPT-180 Classic$4☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
03. Hamilton Beach - Classic$2☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
04. Breville - BTA 830XL$$$$4 (2 x long)☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
05. Cuisinart - CPT-122 Plastic$2☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
06. KRUPS - KH734D$4☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
07. Oster - Jelly Bean$2☆☆☆☆☆☆
08. Bella - Pro Series$$4☆☆☆☆
09. KitchenAid - KMT223$$$2☆☆☆
10. Black+Decker - TR2900SSD$2☆☆☆☆☆

Why you need a pop-up toaster

Some may think that there are many ways to heat bread, bagels and frozen waffles. An oven that can handle a Thanksgiving turkey can surely accommodate a couple slices of bread and a pan over the stove can also toast bagels. So, why even bother with a slot toaster?

Slot toasters are the best and easiest way to make toast and a lot of other foods quickly and consistently.

Making toast in the oven, or even in one of the winners from our review of the best toaster ovens, makes inferior toast. Toast from the oven is often flaky and dry. Because of an oven’s size, the heat source is far from the bread and with the volume of air inside, food items dry as they cook. That’s why we marinate vegetables and baste turkey.

In a slot toaster, because the source of heat is so close and the duration is so quick, the moisture inside your bagels and bread doesn’t escape. This creates the crispy outside you want but leaves a warm, soft and chewy inside. Perfect toast.

You can also make toast on a stovetop or even a portable induction cooktop, and it’s certainly quicker than waiting for the oven to preheat, but the pan has to be actively tended and then washed. The ability to simply push a button or lever and then move on to other tasks makes a slot toaster much more convenient — particularly for those mornings when minutes seem to fly by as you try to get out the door.

Beyond toast

Clearly, the toaster is an ideal tool for making toast, frozen breakfast treats and bagels. But the vertical slots of a toaster make it less versatile than a toaster oven when you’re heating or cooking other food. That is, it was, until someone invented a clever hack.

Toaster bags, made of heat-resistant and food-safe silicone or Teflon, allow you to cook pretty much anything that will fit in the slots. The bags, which trap any crumbs, melting cheese, or loose topping are washable and reusable. This is now the quickest, cleanest and easiest way to reheat last night’s pizza or create gourmet sandwiches.

With the confined shape of toaster bags, you can also add your favorite toppings or spreads before toasting. Grilled cheese or even peanut butter sandwiches come out hot and ready without any extra dishes. During our testing, we even made toaster panini with chicken, pesto and goat cheese.

You can also make hot sandwiches in a waffle maker, but as we found out in our review of the best waffle makers, even a non-stick waffle iron takes much more work to clean up than a toaster bag.

What to look for in a toaster

Number of slots

2 vs 4 slot toaster

A single person or couple will most likely be served well with a two-slot toaster while a larger family would probably benefit from the extra slots, particularly when multiple people need to use it in a short time period.

The size of your kitchen and your aesthetic taste will also dictate how much of your counter space you want to dedicate to a toaster. For a 300-square-foot studio with a small kitchen, a two-slot toaster is probably going to be the right decision.

Crumb tray

toaster crumb tray

The crumb tray, a small, thin, metallic sheet that slides out from the bottom of the toaster, is a crucial feature. All of our finalists have crumb trays and we strongly advise against buying a toaster without one.

The tray catches all of the inevitable crumbs and debris that flake off bread during the toasting process. Instead of these small fragments of food continuing to burn at the bottom of your toaster for all eternity, you simply pull out the tray after use and dispose of the collected waste.

Slot size

toaster slot width

The length and width of the slots will determine what can actually fit inside and smaller slots limit your ability to toast larger and more varied food items. The emerging standard width is 1½ inches, which is featured in all except one of our finalists. The lengths hover between five and six inches, with the exception of the Breville Diecast Smart Toaster, which sports two unique 10-inch long slots.

Features

toaster features settings and buttons

Beyond simple toasting, there are several other pre-programmed features that may come equipped that change exactly how it heats a given food item. For example, the most common feature is the bagel setting, which makes a darker, crispier inside and prevents over-cooking the crust of a bagel by changing the intensity of the different heated coils. While all of our finalists have a bagel function, they are not all created equal.

Another popular setting is the frozen or defrost button, which is designed for food coming directly from the freezer. Again, all of our finalists have this feature, but it performs differently from model to model.

Some frozen settings simply increase the time of a given cycle while others actually lower the intensity of the heat or more gradually increase it to prevent burning the outside before the inside is done.

Other popular features to consider are levers, push buttons, LED displays, sound alerts, countdown timers, a cancel function and the ability to lift the food high enough out of the slots to make removing it by hand easy and safe.

Price

More expensive toasters almost always look sharper and sleeker, but they don’t necessarily make drastically better toast. Cheaper options may take a bit longer and produce less even coloring and texture than pricier models, which often have more wattage and more heated wires.

It’s likely that a more expensive model, made with higher quality, more durable components, will last longer. Some offer warranties while others don’t. In the end, your budget and personal preferences will help determine which one of our top seven will be your favorite.

How we tested

Speed and consistency

toast comparison

We wanted to find out how reliably each toaster produced the same shading and texture on the same medium setting over five toasting cycles. Everyone likes their toast a certain way, but can the toaster predictably create that certain way for you every time?

For this test, we used slices of Wonder Bread and set each finalist to its middle setting. We also wanted to see any difference between slots, so we cycled through the slots over the five consecutive toasting cycles.

All of the finalists we tested decrease the amount of time per cycle progressively as the machine gets hotter. The average time to reach a medium toast the first time around was two minutes, 47 seconds. That dropped to an average of two minutes, 15 seconds on the second round, with further incremental drops each round.

The toasters that created the most consistent toast from rounds one to five adjusted the time toast spent in the slots while also altering the intensity of the heat. The toaster with the smallest variance in time between rounds, the Oster Jelly Bean, also produced some of the most similarly toasted slices round after round. Other toasters that offered close to uniform consistency were the Cuisinart and the Hamilton Beach.

Not only were the Cuisinart and Oster Jelly Bean toasters reliable, they were also the two fastest, both with first round times of two minutes and two seconds. At just under four minutes, the now-discontinued Frigidaire – Professional was by far the slowest to achieve a medium toast.

Toast quality

toaster evenness

After observing the speed and consistency of multiple rounds, we turned our attention to the quality of the toast itself. We wanted to see bread that had been evenly colored from left to right, top to bottom and on both sides. The ideal toast would be crispy on the outside without being too dry or flaky all the way through — a bit of a crunch with a warm and light interior.

Many of the toasters provide an evenly shaded slice from left to right on the same side, but there is a discernable difference between the top and bottom, with the bottom almost always being a bit darker. There was also often a large variation from one side of the bread to the other.

Only the toast made with the Hamilton Beach toaster was the same on both sides of the bread. All of the others produced toast with a lighter side and a darker side. With some, the difference was very slight, like the Kitchenaid and Cuisinart, but many were noticeably darker on one side, as with the KRUPS toaster.

Making a taste comparison between the models is difficult, as everyone has different taste buds, different expectations and different reactions. However, the toast that emerged from the Frigidaire toaster had a clearly different texture than all the others. It seemed denser and compressed — the edges crumbled and flaked with even the most careful handling.

Settings

Bagels

All of the toasters on our list of finalists include a bagel setting. Most also have a decal near the slots that illustrates what direction to face the sliced side of the bagel. The goal is to toast a bagel with a golden brown, crispy cut side and a warmed but still chewy opposite side. We used fresh bagels that we cut in half right before toasting, and also double-checked the mode with a slice of bread to see how big the difference between sides really was.

The bagel setting works by increasing the heat on just one side of the slot. Clearly this technology has been well-developed, as we were pleased with most all of the bagels that popped up. The one disappointment was the Oster Jelly Bean, which seemed to do the exact same thing to both sides of the bagel. The medium bagel setting was also much darker than we would have expected.

Krups earned some points here with a bagel setting that crisped the inside while only just warming the outside of the bagel.

Frozen

In order to test the ability of the direct-from-the-freezer setting, we set each toaster to either frozen or defrost and lowered a Pillsbury Toaster Strudel into the slot. The goal was a crispy, flakey exterior and a warm — but not too hot — gooey filling inside. In addition to our texture and taste observations, we used an infrared thermometer to measure the temperature of both the outside surface and the inside filling of the pastry after one, and if necessary, two rounds of toasting.

Both the Cuisinart and the KRUPS needed two rounds on frozen set to medium to cook a finished product that was ready to eat. After just one cycle, the pastry was just barely warm to the touch, with a cool, less-than-delicious center. The other models all succeeded in making a Toaster Strudel with an interior temperature above 160 degrees after the first cycle.

Slot size

While all the toasters we tested are marketed as having large, wide slots, we wanted to see how the machines actually handled larger slices of bread. We cut several loaves of french bread into ½-inch, one-inch and 1½-inch-wide segments and ran them through our finalists. For reference, a slice of Wonder Bread is about half an inch.

As the slices get wider, they get closer to the heated wires inside the slots and the edges darken quicker and more dramatically than the middle surface area of the bread. If you typically enjoy a traditional sliced toast at any given setting, you may want to decrease the setting for thicker slices since it will toast quicker.

For some of our finalists, one-inch-thick bread came out a bit uneven in terms of shading and quality. Several toasters, including the Hamilton Beach and the Oster Jelly Bean could not accommodate the 1½-inch cut pieces; their slots were simply too narrow. The others performed with varying degrees of success, with the clear winner in this category being the Breville.

Surface heat

Obviously the inside of the toaster will be hot, but the outside should remain relatively cool to be handled easily after use. Again, we used our infrared thermometer to take the temperature of the outside surface of the toaster after one and two rounds on the medium setting.

Most of our finalists hung around the mid 80s and low 90s (F°) for surface temperature, which is warm but not dangerously hot. However, the Oster Jelly Bean shot up above 100 after just one round and to 122 degrees after the second. At this temperature, the toaster was very hot to the touch and couldn’t be moved without oven mitts for several minutes.

Other features

Finally, we tried to take into account all the other aspects of the user experience that are hard to quantify but are still important. We looked at how easily the crumb trays are removed and cleaned and how efficiently they trap crumbs inside the machine. We spent hours assessing how intuitive and easy each toaster is to use.

We observed LED screens, timers, lever lifts that raise the toast higher out of the slots, and push buttons that automatically lower and raise the food. We compared dings, beeps and the feeling you get from using and simply looking at the toaster in the kitchen to help determine the best of the best.

Best overall: Cuisinart – Touch to Toast 4-Slice

cuisinart toaster

Across all of our testing, the Cuisinart – CPT-440 Touch to Toast performed extremely well. It is incredibly consistent, very fast and shades the entire surface of sliced bread evenly. The four slots are wide enough to accommodate large, 1½-inch-wide food, the dual crumb trays catch a large majority of debris and the stainless steel finish looks sharp. It’s a well-performing tool and a great addition to any kitchen.

During our test for consistency, the Cuisinart continued to decrease the time bread spent lowered into the slots, ensuring that a medium toast looked the same after five rounds as it did after the first.

The toast was also well-colored from top to bottom and side to side, with just the slightest detectable difference front to back. The outside was hot and crispy while the inside maintained a moistness and chewy mouthfeel that was just perfect.

At just two minutes and two seconds to complete the first round of medium toasting, the Cuisinart toaster is the fastest four-slot toaster and matched the fastest two slot, the Oster Jelly Bean. Four slices of toast in just over two minutes puts the Cuisinart toaster in a league of its own.

Top Pick: Cuisinart Touch to Toast 4-Slice

The Cuisinart toaster is our top pick overall thanks to its fast and consistent toasting and simple controls.

Because of the shorter toasting time, the Cuisinart does not accumulate the surface heat that other machines do. In fact, the Cuisinart is the only finalist we tested that stayed below a 90-degree surface temperature after multiple runs. It can safely and easily be moved around the kitchen immediately after use.

The one test the Cuisinart toaster failed to hit out of the park was frozen food. It required a second round of toasting to bring the interior temperature of the Toaster Strudel up to the desired heat. While that may not be ideal, it still got the job done in a timely manner.

The bagel setting functions as it should and the bagels we enjoyed from the Cuisinart toaster were expertly crisped on the cut side and warm and soft on the outside. Just place the bagel in the slots as pictured on the machine and press the bagel button.

The extra-large slots can handle food items that are 1½ inches wide, so toasted sandwiches, frozen pretzels, or left-over pizza can easily be accommodated in a toaster bag. Keep in mind that you may want to lower the setting for extra-wide foods, as they do get close to the heated wires.

We also really like the design of the Cuisinart. The push-button automatic chamber feels futuristic and the heating mechanism slowly squeezes the food once it’s lowered to guarantee an even, complete toasting. The large LED screen is easy to view and the settings are intuitive.

cuisinart auto lowering animation

At just under $85 for high-quality components and craftsmanship that make great toast and can handle so many more common cooking tasks, the Cuisinart four-slot toaster is our pick for best overall.

Key takeaways:

  • The Cuisinart – Touch to Toast Leverless toaster consistently produces the same high quality every time it’s used.
  • It creates evenly colored and crisped toast, with settings that are easy to adjust on an LED screen.
  • Its four 1½ -inch-wide slots accommodate a variety of food.
  • It toasted faster than any other four-slot toaster.
  • The push button mechanical lowering and automatic raising are luxurious and futuristic.

Best Value: Cuisinart – CPT-180 Classic

Cuisinart - CPT-180

Cuisinart has a toaster to fit every budget. The Touch to Toast model above is still the best of the best unless you need to toast something that won’t fit in the slots, but we know some readers want a value-priced toaster instead. The Cuisinart – CPT-180 4-Slice Classic gets you the impeccable toast quality of the 440, but at a much lower price. (It’s a bit easier to find, too.)

When you drop down from the Touch to Toast model to the Classic, you’re giving up the motorized levers, countdown timer, and a little bit of quality in the parts and finish.
That said, the internal parts of Cusinart’s toasters all seem to be very similar, if not identical.

The one test where the stainless-sided Classic model pulls away from its siblings is in the defrost mode: For whatever reason, this was the only Cuisinart toaster we tested that kept heating until a frozen pastry was a piping-hot 157 degrees on the inside. That’s not quite as hot as the Breville or Hamilton Beach results, but nearly perfect for a quick snack.

Best Value: Cuisinart - CPT-180

If you're looking for nearly-perfect toast out of an affordable toaster, this model is our pick. Evenly-toasted results every time. This model works better on the defrost setting, though the slots are narrower.

There are a few things holding this toaster back from the very top spot, however.
For one, the slots are slightly narrow, with the wire holders only accepting slices 1.2 inches wide compared to the full 1.5 inch capacity of the 440. The rest of the build quality is a little bit lower than the 440 as well, with knobs and buttons that feel more like a $40 toaster than a $60 toaster should. And if we want to be really picky, the toast from this and the other Cuisinart toasters was often a little darker on one side than the other.

When all the crumbs are swept away, the heating element and temperature controls are what count most, and this Cuisinart is as good as it gets.

Key takeaways:

  • The Cuisinart CPT-180, like the 440, consistently pops out great toast.
  • For defrosting toaster pastries, the 180 was the best among Cuisinart models we tested.
  • Narrower slots make this model slightly less versatile than the 440.
  • The 180 is not the cheapest toaster we tested, but the price for performance is excellent.

Budget 2-slice: Hamilton Beach – 22790

hamiltion beach toaster

If a four-slot toaster gives away too much precious counter space and you’re in the market for something more compact, the Hamilton Beach toaster is the right choice. And at under $25, it offers the best value.

The Hamilton Beach toaster offers even shading over the entire surface of bread and the same on both sides. However, it does tend to toast darker in consecutive uses, so you may want to adjust the setting as you go, if you’re making lots of toast or bagels.

Best 2-Slice Option: Hamilton Beach - 22790

A compact and inexpensive toaster that's great for those who only need to toast two slices at a time.

Both the defrost setting and the bagel setting operate extremely well. Our breakfast pastry was a hot 225 degrees on the outside and a warm 185 degrees on the inside, perfect and ready to eat after just one round. Our bagel had the optimal temperature and texture on both the crust side and cut side.

The compact design of the Hamilton Beach toaster means slightly smaller slots, measuring just past 1¼ inch wide. While that may somewhat limit your options, it is a necessary trade for a smaller footprint and a high-quality product.

One thing the Hamilton does better than any other machine we tested is making it easy to remove your food. The lever can be raised beyond its neutral resting position to bring the food clear of the hot slots. This allows you to get your food out without having to resort to a utensil or worrying about burning your fingers.

Key takeaways:

  • The Hamilton Beach toaster gives quality results on a budget.
  • “Toast boost” levers lifts food higher for easier removal.
  • Batch-to-batch results will vary more than with our top picks.
  • Defrosts a frozen pastry perfectly after one round, and

Most versatile: Breville – 4-Slice Long Slot

breville toaster

The Breville toaster (about $180) is a two-slot toaster unlike all others. It can fit four regular slices of bread, two bagels, or two larger pieces of sourdough within its two 10-by-1.75-inch slots. This can come in handy when toasting irregular slices of bread, making paninis, or reheating a slice of pizza with a toaster bag.

Its modern matte stainless steel design features a motor that slowly lowers and automatically raises the slices when they’re toasted without the user manually pushing down a lever and eliminating the need for a sudden pop-up when the toast is done.

Most Versatile: Breville - 4-Slice Long Slot

The Breville is ideal for those who toast breads of all shapes and sizes.

During the evenness tests, we found that the Breville’s toast was close to the same shade across the slice, but the crust was slightly darker than the middle. However, after toasting five consecutive slices, the toast increased in doneness and by the last slice, the edges were burned.

The toaster continued to accumulate heat as our testing progressed and it was hotter to the touch at the end of several rounds than most other toasters we tested. After one toasting, which lasted two minutes and 40 seconds, the outside temperature was 85 degrees, and after the second one-minute and 55-second toasting, it was 91 degrees.

During our frozen pastry test, the Breville performed very well and the Toaster Strudel was perfectly toasted after just one round on the frozen setting — even though the outer edges ended up a bit more toasted than the middle. The outside crust came in at 210 degrees and the inside filling was 162.

When it came to toasting bagels, we found that the bagel setting performed as it should; the outside was still soft but warmed up and the sliced inside was browned and toasted. However, the inside of the bagel was a bit too dark on the medium setting. Those who don’t want their bagel too brown should take it down to a lower level.

The Breville can accommodate bread just a bit wider than normal and a slice much longer than any other toaster we tested. However, it did brown the edges of the bread more than the middle, which is a pretty common trait as breads increase in thickness.

The Lift & Look button allows the user to move the slices up and down slightly during the toasting process to observe the shade of the toast. As it toasts, its LED display shows a visual countdown of when the toast will be done. When it’s finished toasting, it slowly raises the slices and emits a soft beep, which is adjustable in volume.

After we finished the testing, it came time to clear the crumb tray. We found that it’s easy to remove but doesn’t cover a large amount of surface area under the toaster. Compared with other toasters, many more crumbs were caught on the floor of the toaster and less ended up in the crumb tray.

Key takeaways:

  • The Breville – BTA 830XL is perfect for artisanal breads like sourdough.
  • Two extra-long slots give this a wider, narrower footprint than other four-slice toasters.
  • LED tracking light that displays the progress of the toast is a great touch on a minimalist design.

The other finalists we tested

The other toasters we tested performed well while making toast, crisping bagels, and heating frozen foods. However, there were some discernible differences in user experience and results that led us to our conclusions.

Cuisinart – CPT-122

Cuisinart - CPT-122

Cuisinart’s line is carefully segmented by price and feature set: each retailer has a slightly different model, though most of them produce very similar toast. If you go to Home Depot or Wal-Mart, you’ll find the CPT-122 2-slice offering in plastic at the lowest price point.

The major practical difference between this toaster and the CPT-160 or -180 “Classic” models is the insulating nature of the plastic sides: the hottest spot we could find on the sides of the plastic toaster was 97 degrees after toasting most of a loaf of bread, compared to 130-degree hotspots on other toasters. Safety concerns really aren’t much different, though: Most toasters won’t burn you if you brush your hand against the side, and this plastic model still has metal slots that concentrate the 900 watts of heat up top.

The Plastic Cuisinart, like the top-of-the-line digital model, requires multiple runs of “defrost” to actually get the inside of a frozen pastry hot. The Cuisinart – CPT-180 or Hamilton Beach – Classic Chrome toaster fared better in that test, but the plastic-sided Cuisinart is a good backup budget option if you can’t get those model.

KRUPS – KH734D 4-Slot

KRUPS toaster

The KRUPS 4-Slice Toaster is made of mirror-finished stainless steel and has a clean, modern look. Like the other four-slice toasters, it takes up a large amount of counter space, but its rounded edges give a sleeker, more circular appearance. For under $60, this is an impressively well-made toaster.

It proved itself as one of the most consistent toasters when we ran multiple batches. It reliably produced the same shading, texture and temperature across five slices of bread in our consistency test. However, it toasted one side of the bread more than the other and the bottoms of some slices didn’t toast as well as the rest of the slice. Overall, the Krups is also calibrated on the lighter side. Most users will find themselves only using settings four through six.

Bagels toasted perfectly with the KRUPS toaster. The inside was crunchy and a toasty golden brown and the outside was warm without getting too crisp. The Krups bagel mode is perfect if you’re one of those fancy people (like Sting) who like toast done on one side. Just remember to set it fairly high if you want to see some actual browning.

On the whole, there are a few more issues holding the Krups back. When it’s done toasting the popping sound is fairly subtle. Then, even when it’s fully raised, smaller slices of bread and our breakfast pastry did not clear the edges of the slot, making pulling them out tricky, with lots of care needed.

As with our top pick, the Krups didn’t heat our frozen toaster pastry through on the defrost setting, and the filling was only 88 degrees. In comparison, the Cusinart – Classic nailed it on the first cycle.

Oster – Jelly Bean

The Oster Jelly Bean toaster is a two-slot machine that produces a medium toast that looks exactly the same every time. It also does it faster than any four-slot toaster, popping out medium toast in under two minutes in every round after the first.

While the Oster does have a bagel setting, it does not appear to operate any differently from the traditional toast setting. Our bagel came out crispy and a bit dry on both sides.

The Oster’s exterior also heats up much more than our other finalists. After just two cycles on medium, the sides of the machine were 120 degrees, nearly 20 degrees hotter than any other toaster and very hot to the touch.

Bella – Pro Series 4-Slice

Bella has our attention after they cleaned up in our waffle iron review, so we tested the Best-Buy exclusive Bella – Pro Series 4-slice toaster on account of a second-best overall rank in Consumer Reports’s toaster reviews. It failed to win our hearts.

For about $10 less, the Cuisinart Classic model had a more balanced range of toast settings, and the Bella didn’t differentiate enough on the bagel setting. Bella’s settings all ran a little longer than Cuisinart’s, and the toast was always darker on one edge.

KitchenAid – KMT223 2-Slice

The Kitchenaid toaster is a sleek, high-end, two-slot toaster that looks the best out of our top seven when sitting on the kitchen counter. It too has the automatic push button lowering that is fun to use and adjusts to different sizes of food. The crumb tray is also very well-designed, released by pushing on the back instead of pulling from the front.

During our testing, we observed that the Kitchenaid toaster failed to modify the time and heat intensity in consecutive uses. Each slice of toast was darker and drier than the one before. There was also a clear difference between the bottom and top of the bread itself. The bottom half emerged darker than the top. The Kitchenaid performed very well on both the bagel and the frozen food tests, however.

Black+Decker – TR2900SSD 2-slice Stainless

We searched far and wide for another reputable, easy-to-find budget toaster, and the Black+Decker – TR2900SSD at Target is a near-miss. This two-slice toaster with brushed steel finish is fairly attractive, and they were least trying to be a little bit different with the cancel button in the middle of the control knob.

Black+Decker delivers a good slice of toast, but the consistency across batches wasn’t as good as Cuisinart and the Bagel setting is barely different from the toast setting. It also takes 40 seconds longer to toast than the Cuisinart. At about $5 more than the Hamilton Beach, there’s really no reason to prefer this model.

Frigidaire – Professional 4-Slice (discontinued)

We tested this digital-control toaster in our original roundup to see how it stacked up against the other premium models. We liked the reflective stainless steel finish and the digital LED countdown timer, but toast quality was disappointing. Frigidaire has discontinued this model and hasn’t replaced it.

The bottom line

Slot toasters are incredibly efficient and provide the perfect texture and toast shade quicker, easier and more reliably than other methods. With the use of reusable toaster bags, a good toaster becomes a versatile and almost essential appliance for any kitchen.

Our pick for the best slot toaster is the Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless 4-Slice Toaster because of its consistency, usability and value. The four slots are wide enough to handle almost any food; the pre-programmed settings for bagels and frozen food work exceptionally well; and it looks and feels sharp and modern.

If those premium digital control features aren’t what you’re looking for, the performance from the more conventional Cuisinart – CPT-180 is also very good.

For a bit more versatility, the Breville Diecast Smart Toaster offers unique 10-inch-long slots that are perfect for artisanal breads or reheating pizza. It also includes great features like A Bit More, which gives your food just a little more toasting, plus Lift & Look, which lets you quickly see the food without halting the heating cycle.

Finally, if a compact 2-slot toaster is the right decision for your kitchen, the Hamilton Beach Classic provides the best quality without sacrificing a lot of counter space. It’s a good value and makes great toast every time.

Top Pick: Cuisinart Touch to Toast 4-Slice

The Cuisinart toaster performed best across the board in our testing, and produces the most consistently high-quality toast when compared to all of our finalists.

Daniel Jackson, Writer

Daniel is a Canadian farm boy who grew up to be a nerd with a literature degree and too many hobbies to count. He emigrated from Canada to California in 2013, and now writes for Your Best Digs full-time. Daniel remains unapologetic about Canadian spelling, serial commas, and the destruction of expensive travel mugs.

More Reviews